Chief financial officer’s review
 |
|
| This year’s results are characterised
by a strong performance of the
South African business, improved
profitability of the UK business and
several corporate actions to improve
capital efficiencies. |
Peter Nelson Chief Financial Officer

|
This review provides further insight into the financial position,
performance and recent major developments of Netcare,
and should be read in conjunction with the annual financial
statements.
Corporate activity
A number of corporate transactions were concluded during the
year under review. These included:
- Successful listing of R1,7 billion 6% convertible bonds due
2011 on the Singapore Stock Exchange;
- Acquisition of the remaining interest in Community Hospital
Group (effective 2 October 2007);
- Rebalancing of shareholder interest in General Healthcare
Group;
- Repayment of facility A of the offshore debt (£83 million);
- Issuance of R400 million redeemable preference shares;
- Continued successful refinancing of short-term debt through
the domestic medium-term note programme at attractive
rates; and
- Extinguishing of the Netpartner debt through the issuance of
47,4 million Netcare shares.
The profitability of all operations was largely in line with
Netcare’s communicated expectations and capital expenditure
on South African based operations remained at high levels
reflecting Netcare’s continued belief in and support for the
growth of the home base. Particularly pleasing was the
commissioning of two new hospitals, namely Blaauwberg and
Alberlito, which are expected to deliver positive cash flow
during 2008. Significant expenditure has been spent on medical
equipment (R633 million) and IT (SAP infrastructure).
Acquisition of the remaining shares in Community Hospital
Group (CHG)
In August 2007 the Competition Tribunal ruled in favour of
Netcare acquiring the remaining 56,3% interest in CHG, which
owns five private hospitals (three located in Gauteng and two
situated in Cape Town) with 682 licensed beds. With effect from
2 October 2007 CHG became a wholly owned subsidiary of
Netcare and will be consolidated from this date. The results of
CHG have been equity accounted for the 2007 financial year.
The acquisition consideration was settled through the issuance
of 14,2 million Netcare shares on 5 October 2007 at the closing
Netcare share price of R11,89 at the acquisition date. In
addition, Netcare assumed debt of approximately R140 million.
Rebalancing of shareholder interest in General Healthcare
Group (GHG)
On initial acquisition of GHG on 12 May 2006, Netcare acquired
a 52,6% interest in the UK’s leading private hospital operator.
It was noted at the time that this holding was expected to
dilute to 50,1% following the allotment of equity to GHG local
management. After a process of significant restructuring
within the UK operations the GHG Local Management Equity
Participation Programme was finalised in July 2007. Whilst
Netcare’s direct interest in GHG reduced to 50,1% as originally
envisaged, Netcare continues to account for an effective
interest of 52,3% due to the consolidation into the Netcare
group of the entities (SPVs) housing local management’s
interests.
The allotment of preference shares set aside for GHG local
management was not fully subscribed. Consequently, there
was an imbalance amongst the original consortium members
in respect of their preference share investments. In order to
restore equilibrium amongst the partners, Netcare acquired a
further 9 736 390 preference shares with a face value of
£1 each for a consideration of R137 million, thereby increasing
its direct interest in the preference capital of GHG to 54,2%.
Elimination of the cross holding in Netpartner
In December 2006 the final tranche of the Netpartner debt
comprising a R315 million loan and a R255 million derivative
liability was repaid through the issue of 47,4 million Netcare
shares. This brings to a satisfactory conclusion the complex
cross holding arrangement that existed with Netpartner whilst
providing the added benefits of simplification of the accounting
and supporting structures and improved transparency of the
Group.
Operating results
Financial targets
A number of financial targets were set at the end of the 2006
financial year, as detailed below:
| 30 September |
Target |
Actual 2007 |
Actual 2006 |
| SA Revenue growth (%) |
11,0 – 12,0 |
14,9 |
11,3 |
| UK Revenue (£m) |
650 – 700 |
689 |
265 |
| SA EBITDA margin (%) |
19,0 – 20,0 |
19,0 |
19,4 |
| UK EBITDA margin (%) |
26,0 |
24,8 |
14,7 |
| SA Net debt:EBITDA (times) |
3,0 |
3,1 |
3,6 |
| UK Net debt:EBITDA (times) |
10,0 |
10,3 |
19,1 |
| SA CFROI© (%) |
12,0 |
14,8 |
13,1 |
| SA Capex (Rm) |
800 – 900 |
800 |
849 |
| UK Capex (£m) |
40 – 50 |
42 |
20 |
We are pleased to report on the successful attainment of most of
these targets. The SA net debt:EBITDA ratio fell only marginally
short of the stated goal. The UK EBITDA margin was negatively
impacted by non-recurring costs of R79 million (see UK operating
results). The exclusion of these costs improves the UK net debt:
EBITDA ratio to 10 times, which is in line with target, and the UK
EBITDA margin to 25,6%, slightly short of target.
South Africa
The key financial performance indicators are as follows:
| 30 September |
2007 Rm |
2006 Rm |
| Revenue |
8 869 |
7 720 |
| EBITDA |
1 685 |
1 494 |
| Depreciation and amortisation |
279 |
256 |
| Operating profit |
1 406 |
1 238 |
| Net interest paid |
456 |
152 |
| Profit before tax |
951 |
1 210 |
| Taxation |
278 |
322 |
| Profit for the year from continuing operations |
673 |
888 |
The South African business delivered excellent results with
revenue up 14,9% to R8 869 million boosted by a particularly
strong last quarter and two new hospitals. Operating profit was
up 13,6% to R1 406 million whilst the operating profit margin
remained relatively flat at 15,9% compared to 16,0% in 2006.
The operating leverage was offset by the start-up operating
losses of R16 million from the two new hospitals opened
during the year and increased nursing salaries and training
expenditure. The 2006 operating profit was positively impacted
by the release of the R85 million deferred lease liability relating
to the Umhlanga property, offset by the negative impact of the
HPFL BEE share expense of R65 million.
Net interest paid for the South African operations at
R456 million is significantly higher than the prior year
of R152 million, driven largely by the financing of the Group’s
significant capital expenditure programme including the
commissioning of two new hospitals. Consequently interest
cover has declined from 8,1 times in 2006 to 3,1 times in the
current year.
Depreciation and amortisation of R279 million is 9,0% higher
than the prior year’s figure of R256 million, reflecting the
steadily increasing levels of capital spend on infrastructure and
medical equipment.
United Kingdom
The key financial performance indicators are as follows:
| 30 September |
2007 Rm |
2007 £m |
20061 Rm |
| Revenue |
9 738 |
689 |
3 432 |
| EBITDA |
2 411 |
171 |
504 |
| Depreciation and amortisation |
765 |
55 |
286 |
| Operating profit |
1 646 |
116 |
218 |
| Net interest paid |
1 734 |
123 |
679 |
| Loss before tax |
(64) |
(5) |
(531) |
| Taxation |
(377) |
27 |
(93) |
| Profit/(loss) for the year |
313 |
22 |
(438) |
1 Includes the results of GHG for the period 12 May 2006 to
30 September 2006
The exchange rates applicable for the conversion of the
international results from Pound Sterling to South African Rand
are as follows:
| |
2007 R:£ |
2006 R:£ |
| Closing rate at 30 September |
14,03 |
14,53 |
| Average rate (1 October – 30 September) |
14,13 |
11,90 |
| Average rate (12 May 2006 – 30 September 2006) |
|
13,04 |
| Acquisition rate at 12 May 2006 |
|
11,73 |
Fluctuations in exchange rates have had a significant impact on
the reported results quoted in South African Rand. The average
rate of exchange applicable for the 2007 results weakened by
8% against the prevailing rate for the 2006 period, whereas the
year end rate for balance sheet purposes strengthened by 3%.
Revenue for the UK business was R9 738 million
(£689 million) driven by a 1,7% increase in total caseload
year-on-year. A strong operational focus translated into
EBITDA of R2 411 million (£171 million) and an operating
profit of R1 646 million (£116 million). The results were
negatively impacted by the following items:
- Restructuring and retrenchment costs of R34 million
(£2 million);
- Transaction costs of R25 million (£2 million); and
- NHS mobilisation and bid costs of R20 million (£1 million).
The 2006 results included restructuring costs of R280 million
(£21 million) and NHS bid costs of R39 million (£3 million).
The operating profit margin adjusted to exclude these costs is
17,7% (2006: 15,6%) and the EBITDA margin is 25,6% (2006:
24,0%).
Net interest paid, amounted to R1 734 million (£123 million),
and was impacted by favourable movements in that portion of
the interest rate swaps recognised in the income statement of
R58 million (£4 million).
GHG benefited from a deferred tax release of R372 million
(£27 million) due to an announced 2% reduction in the UK
statutory rate of tax. Excluding this amount the UK business
results reduced the Group headline earnings per share by
15,3 cents.
Group
The Group results for the year ended 30 September 2007
reflect revenue, EBITDA and operating profit significantly ahead
of the prior year. The prior year results include GHG for the
period from 12 May 2006 (ie four-and-a-half months) and Prime
Cure Holdings Limited from February 2006 (ie eight months).
The key financial performance indicators are as follows:
| 30 September |
2007 Rm |
2007 £m |
% change |
| Revenue |
18 607 |
11 152 |
66,8 |
| EBITDA |
4 034 |
2 120 |
90,3 |
| Operating profit |
2 990 |
1 578 |
89,5 |
| Return on ordinary shareholders' equity (%) |
30,0 |
23,0 |
30,4 |
The Group revenue and operating profit contribution for the year
ended 30 September 2007 can be analysed as follows:

Attributable earnings of associates at R32 million are
14,3% ahead of prior year (R28 million). This includes
primarily attributable earnings from Healthshare Health
Solutions and Community Hospital Group.
The Group tax line reflects a credit of R99 million. This is
a consequence of a deferred tax release of R372 million
(£27 million) following the announcement of a 2% reduction
in the UK statutory tax rate. The effective tax rate of the SA
operations is 27,4% due to assessed losses which have been
fully utilised by September 2007. As such the tax rate in future
years will be more closely aligned to the statutory rates of the
UK and South Africa.
The 2007 basic HEPS for the group increased to 77,6 cents
per share. The South African operations contributed 77,1 cents
to Group HEPS, reduced by GHG to the extent of 15,3 cents
before the effect of the UK tax rate reduction, which added
15,8 cents. Headline earnings for the year ended 30 September 2006 have been restated to comply with the
recently issued SAICA Circular 8/2007, Headline Earnings.
This circular applies to financial periods ending on or after
31 August 2007. In terms of this circular long-term debt
reorganisation costs (previously excluded from headline earnings)
are not recognised within the definition of re-measurements and
are consequently now included in headline earnings. The effect
of the change has been to reduce the 2006 headline earnings per
share (HEPS) from 56,2 cents to 44,3 cents.
Balance sheet
The key balance sheet performance indicators are as follows:
| Group |
|
|
| 30 September |
2007 Rm |
2006 Rm |
| Total equity |
8 582 |
6 236 |
| Total liabilities |
41 957 |
44 302 |
| |
50 539 |
50 538 |
The Group’s investments are funded primarily from operating
cash flow. Any shortfalls are usually short term and are funded
from banking facilities.
Equity increased by R2,3 billion during the year. This is due to
the issue of 47,4 million shares (R617 million) on the Netpartner
unwind and R1 136 million (including minority interest) arising
on cash flow hedge reserves due to the increase in UK
long-term interest rates as well as growth in retained earnings.
The appreciation of the South African Rand against the Pound
Sterling impacted the balance sheet reducing total equity by
R226 million and total debt by R983 million.
Netcare’s debt comprises the following:
| 30 September |
2007 Rm |
Non-recourse debt Rm |
Debt with recourse to Netcare Rm |
2006 Rm |
| Long-term debt |
28 944 |
25 510 |
3 434 |
29 224 |
| Short-term debt |
2 086 |
464 |
1 622 |
2 953 |
| Total debt |
31 030 |
25 974 |
5 056 |
32 177 |
| Less net cash |
(900) |
(1 090) |
190 |
(1 009) |
| Net debt |
30 130 |
24 884 |
5 246 |
31 168 |
Total net debt decreased by 3,3% from September 2006 to
R30 130 million at the year end. R24 884 million of the net debt
relates to GHG and is without recourse to the South African
business and is secured against assets in the United Kingdom.
Net financial liabilities of R1 318 million at 30 September 2006
moved to a R297 million net financial asset position by
30 September 2007. This is mainly as a result of the favourable
movements in the mark-to-market value of the UK long-term
floating-to-fixed interest rate swaps in line with the increase in
long-term interest rates in the UK.
The cost of debt can be summarised as follows:
| South Africa |
| 30 September |
2007 Rm |
2006 Rm |
Average cost of debt** (%) |
| Convertible bond (debt portion) |
1 446 |
|
6,0 |
| Promissory notes |
1 550 |
1 550 |
9,3 |
| Foreign debt |
1 363 |
2 593 |
11,4 |
| Other debt |
697 |
1 474 |
9,5 |
| Total debt |
5 056 |
5 617 |
8,9 |
| United Kingdom |
| 30 September |
2007 £m |
2006 £m |
Average cost of debt** (%) |
| PropCo |
1 644 |
1 650 |
6,3 |
| OpCo |
214 |
214 |
7,7 |
| Other |
7 |
3 |
5,2 |
| Total debt |
1 865 |
1 867 |
6,4 |
** Including hedging
The UK debt has been converted to fixed rates through long-term
floating-to-fixed interest rate swaps covering the full PropCo
borrowings and a notional £200 million of OpCo debt. These
arrangements have protected the Group’s interest rate risk
exposure during the financial year in which Libor increased by
1,2% to 6,3% at 30 September 2007. In light of the rising interest
rate environment and the recent liquidity crisis, the existing
borrowing facilities have locked-in terms that are more favourable
than those currently available in the financial markets.
The UK property market softened in the fourth quarter of 2007
as interest rates rose and financial liquidity diminished. Given
these developments the Group deferred any decision with
regard to the sale of all or part of the UK property portfolio.
Cash flow
Cash generated from operations remains strong at
R3 974 million (2006: R2 129 million) reflecting strong cash
flows from all operations as well as better utilisation of working
capital. South African creditor payments were accelerated
for year end purposes, resulting in a once-off outflow of
R300 million. Taking this into account, working capital is well
within expectations. This is particularly pleasing given the
higher net finance costs for the year.
Material cash outflows during the period include: investment
in the Group’s capital expenditure programme amounting
to R1 389 million (2006: R1 014 million); interest paid of
R2 355 million (2006: R838 million) and reductions of capital
of R347 million (2006: R391 million). Major capital expenditure
items comprise loans to various business associates and
ongoing capital maintenance expenditure at the hospitals.
Significant capital expenditure included amounts spent on:
- Two new hospitals – Alberlito and Blaauwberg;
- Investments in the ICU units at Parklane, Linksfield and
Akasia;
- Trauma units at Pretoria East and Sunward Park;
- Neuro vascular unit at Unitas;
- Cardiac catheterisation laboratories at St Augustine’s and
St Anne’s; and
- Acquisition of the Harbour Hospital property from the
NHS Trust in the UK.
The ongoing investments reflect Netcare’s commitment to
delivering high quality healthcare to its patients through
continued investment in healthcare technology and hospital
infrastructure.
Cash Flow Return on Investment ("CFROI©")
The Group continues to monitor performance, and evaluate
potential investments using the Holt method of CFROI© as
the dominant measure. South African CFROI© of 14,8% has
improved from that achieved in 2006 of 13,1%. We expect this
to improve further in coming years as the benefits from planned
operational improvements within GHG begin to bear results.
In addition, the Group continues to focus on cash value add
investment returns which improve the balance sheet structure
and generate cash flows. CFROI© is a registered trademark
in the United States of Credit Suisse First Boston or its
subsidiaries or affiliates.
Accounting policies
The accounting policies adopted are consistent with those applied
in the prior year except for the following accounting standards,
interpretations and amendments to published accounting
standards which were adopted prior to their effective dates.
- IAS 23 Revision of International Accounting Standard 23
Borrowing costs
- IFRIC Interpretation 10 Interim Financial Reporting and
Impairment
- IFRIC Interpretation 11 Group and Treasury Share
Transactions
- IFRIC Interpretation 12 Service Concession Arrangements
- IFRIC Interpretation 14 IAS 19 – The Limit on a Defined
Benefit Asset, Minimum Funding Requirements and their
Interaction
- Circular 8/2007 Headline Earnings
The requirements of the new standards do not have a
significant impact on the Group and are detailed on
pages 118 to 119. Headline earnings at 30 September 2006
have been restated as a result of Circular 8/2007. The effect
of this has been detailed in note 30 to the annual financial
statements.
The fair value of assets and liabilities of GHG at acquisition
date has been reviewed as required by IFRS3 – Business
Combinations, and where necessary, these values have
been amended and the balance sheet at 30 September 2006
restated. The most significant change was to provide for
deferred tax assets at acquisition of R161 million (£14 million).
The adjustment recognises that the assessed losses in GHG at
acquisition date have value, which is highly probable of being
realised in the short term, and accordingly needs to be brought
to account.
Risk management
Netcare is exposed to a number of external risks which could
significantly impact on results. These risks are monitored on an
ongoing basis and, where possible and in line with our strategy,
appropriate derivative instruments are entered into to mitigate
risk.
Financial risks to which the group is exposed are outlined in
note 31 to the annual financial statements.
Forward looking information
Agreements are currently being concluded to dispose of
Netcare’s 50% interest in the Ampath Holdings Trust, a
trust which manages the Ampath pathology practices and
services rendered. Ampath will continue to be proportionately
consolidated until the Competition Authorities approve the sale.
Our 50% interest in the results of Ampath are separately
disclosed in the table below:
| 30 September |
2007 Rm |
| Revenue |
507 |
| Operating profit |
127 |
| Operating profit margin (%) |
25,0 |
| EBITDA |
137 |
| EBITDA margin (%) |
27,0 |
As already noted, the results of Community will be consolidated
into Netcare with effect from 2 October 2007.
The impact of new accounting standards, interpretations and
amendments to published accounting standards which are not
yet effective and have not been adopted in the current year are
set out on page 130.
Reduction of capital
The board of directors has declared a final reduction of capital
out of share premium of 18 cents per ordinary share, payable
to shareholders recorded in the register of the Company as
at Friday, 18 January 2008. Taken together with the interim
reduction of capital of 13 cents per share, the total reduction of
capital paid and to be paid in respect of the 2007 financial year,
amounts to 31 cents (2006: 27 cents) per ordinary share, an
increase of 14,8% over the period.
|